
Is my SEO agency working, or am I just paying a monthly invoice? If you’ve asked yourself that, you’re not alone, and it’s a fair question to put to any agency you’ve hired.
The short answer: a working agency can show you, in plain words, what it did this month, why it did it, and what changed as a result. If you can’t see the work, the reasons behind it and a trend in enquiries or leads over a few months, something needs a closer look.
This guide covers what good work looks like, the exact questions to send your agency, a checklist you can screenshot, and the warning signs to act on. It’s written as fair advice for owners, not an attack on agencies. Most problems come from poor communication, and a clear request often fixes them.
What a good SEO agency does each month
SEO is slow by nature, so judge your agency on the work and the direction of travel, not on one month’s numbers. Google’s own page on hiring an SEO says a good SEO should explain the changes it makes to your site and the reasoning behind them.
In practice, you should expect:
- A regular report that shows work done, not just rankings. For example, a fortnightly or monthly report listing pages updated, technical fixes made and content published, with links.
- A plan you can read. A short list of what’s coming next month and why it matters for your business.
- Numbers tied to money. Organic enquiries, calls and form submissions, not only traffic. Traffic is visits; enquiries pay the bills.
- Access to your own data. Your Google Search Console and GA4 accounts should be in your name, with the agency added as a user.
- Honest bad news. When something dips, they tell you why and what they’re doing about it.
Here’s what that looks like for a Melbourne business. A Footscray physio clinic should be able to see the new suburb page the agency wrote, the date it went live, and whether booking enquiries from Google grew over the next few months.
A good agency also explains what it won’t do yet, and why. Not every task fits every month, and a clear order of priorities is a sign of a real plan. If you can see that plan, answering “is my SEO agency working?” becomes a matter of checking it against what actually happened.
Still unsure whether your SEO agency is working after reading its last report? Get a free consultation and a second opinion.
What to ask your SEO agency
The fastest way to find out is to ask. Copy the questions below into an email and send them to your account manager. A good agency will be glad you asked.
- “Can you list every task you completed for us in the last 90 days, with links to the pages you changed?”
- “Which of these tasks do you expect to have the biggest effect on enquiries, and why?”
- “How many organic enquiries, calls and form submissions did we get each month this year, compared with last year?”
- “Can you confirm we own our Google Search Console, GA4 and Google Business Profile accounts, and that you’re added as a user?”
- “What are you planning for the next 90 days, and what will we see if it works?”
- “Have you built or bought any links to our site? If so, can you send the list?”
You don’t need to know the answers yourself. You’re checking whether the answers are clear, specific and on time. Vague replies such as “we’re working on authority” with no examples are worth following up.
Give your agency a week to reply, and ask for the answers in writing so you can compare them with next quarter’s report. If you’d rather talk it through, book a call and ask them to share their screen while they walk you through Search Console and GA4. A Richmond accountant, for example, could ask to see exactly which service pages brought in new client enquiries last quarter.
You can also check one thing on your own. In Search Console, go to Performance > Search results, set the date range to the last 12 months, and look at the clicks line. Google’s Performance report help page explains each number. For a plain guide to the rest of your report, read how to read an SEO report without a marketing degree.
Working with an SEO agency: a checklist
Use this checklist every quarter. If you can tick most boxes, your agency is likely doing the work. If you can’t, that’s your agenda for the next meeting.
Reporting gaps are a common reason owners lose trust. The figures below come from a survey of marketing managers about agency reports.
| Finding | Share | What to ask for |
|---|---|---|
| Stopped or considered stopping work with an agency over poor reporting transparency | 62% | A task list with links every month |
| Have seen an agency highlight good numbers and play down weaker ones | 95% | The same core numbers in every report |
Source: ASK BOSCO and OnePoll survey of 100 UK marketing managers, published September 2024. UK sample, so treat it as a guide for Australia.
Warning signs your SEO agency isn’t working
One bad month isn’t a warning sign. A pattern is. Seasonal dips are normal too: a Melbourne retailer may see a quieter January every year. Compare the same months year on year before you decide whether your SEO agency is working. Watch for these:
- Reports change shape every month. If the numbers shown keep changing, ask for the same core set each time: clicks, enquiries, calls and pages worked on.
- No list of completed work. “Ongoing optimisation” with nothing you can click on is a reason to ask for detail.
- You don’t own your accounts. If Search Console or GA4 sits in the agency’s name, ask for ownership to be moved to you now.
- Promises of top rankings by a date. Google says plainly that no one can guarantee a number one ranking.
- Enquiries flat for six months or more with no clear explanation or change of plan.
If you see two or more, put your concerns in writing and ask for a 90-day plan with clear measures. That gives the agency a fair chance to respond. For the signs to look for before you sign, see red flags to watch for when hiring an SEO agency in Melbourne.
Want to see what clear, honest SEO reporting looks like for other Melbourne businesses? See our results.
How we handle reporting and transparency
As an SEO agency Melbourne owners can check up on, we build reporting into every stage of our four-step process:
- Free Consultation and Site Audit: we look at where you stand today, so there’s a baseline to measure from.
- Custom SEO Strategy: a written plan you can read and question.
- In-House Execution: our own team does the work, and we list it for you.
- Grow and Compound: we review results with you and adjust the plan.
Every report shows the tasks completed, with links, and the enquiries tracked in your own GA4 account. If a month is quiet, we say so and explain why. You can see the full range of our SEO services on our homepage.
If you’re still asking “is my SEO agency working?” after a few months, it’s time for a second pair of eyes. Get your free consultation. No lock-in contracts.
Is my SEO agency working? FAQs
How long before I should see results from SEO?
It varies with your competition, your site and how much work is done. Most owners see early signs, such as more impressions, before more enquiries. Judge the trend over several months, not one.
What should a monthly SEO report include?
The work done with links, the plan for next month, and organic enquiries, calls and clicks compared with the same period last year. Rankings can be included, but they shouldn’t be the only measure.
Can I check my SEO agency’s work myself?
Yes. Open Search Console, go to Performance, and compare the last three months with the same three months last year. Then ask your agency to explain the change.
Should I switch agencies if results are slow?
Not straight away. Ask for a clear 90-day plan first. If the answers stay vague, get an independent review. More answers are on our FAQ and blog.
Want results like these for your business?
Book a free, no-obligation consultation with a Melbourne SEO expert.
Get a Free Consultation